The Science of People

Predicting Job Performance: Do Personality Tests Work?

 

Note: This is the first in a two-part series on Predicting Job Performance

HR Leaders, trying to make hiring decisions more objective, often turn to assessment tools to help ensure new hires are the best corporate fit. For nearly 50 years, one of the most commonly used assessments is for personality. Companies use this to try and predict the right “fit” for optimal performance in their business.

What do you think about the effectiveness of personality assessments in performance? Choose Right of Wrong for each of the following statements:

  • 95% of the time when a personality test recommends the candidate will meet your expectations on the job it will be _____ (Right or Wrong)
  • 95% of the time when a personality test recommends the candidate will exceed expectations on the job it will be _____(Right or Wrong)
  • 95% of the time when a personality test recommends the candidate will fail to meet expectations on the job it will be _____(Right or Wrong)

The correct answer to each of the above is “Wrong”.

Even a decade ago, researchers and editors of top psychological journals reporting the results of the predictive power of tests* for hiring discovered something that should have opened eyes and definitively eliminated the use of personality testing for hiring by staffing professionals.

Statistics found that companies using personality tests alone had an incredibly low rate of success in predicting job fit, or either excellence or failure in actual job performance: .22r or less than 6%. The panel of prominent personnel psychologists reported one clear theme: the validities of personality measures are so low that to use them for employee selection should be questioned. One author summed it up stating:

“Why are we looking at personality as a valid predictor of job performance
when the validities are still close to zero?”

Indeed, Peter Capelli, a leading authority on managing workplace talent & Professor of Management, Wharton School, reviewed the history of using personality-based tests for hiring and promotion decisions as far back the 1960s-1980s, and to his surprise, he found that personality-based assessments largely disappeared from the lists of best practices in human resources. However, there was a resurgence of interest in, and use of, personality testing in the 1990s that continues today.

If personality tests don’t work, why are we still using them?

Enthusiasm for the use of personality testing has stemmed from the cost and risks of a bad hire. Zappos CEO Tony Hsieh once estimated bad hires had cost his company over $100M. According to a recent Forbes article, the average cost of on-boarding a new employee can be as high as $240,000, while the US Department of labor suggests the price of a bad hire is 30% of first-year earnings.

When unfilled or poorly filled jobs cost millions, HR is forced to turn to even blunt tools for help. And to their credit, personality tests may provide useful and interesting information about a person, but psychological research is clear: personality measures do little to predict how well a candidate will perform on the job.

They are simply too broad to predict on-the-job performance, as they often don’t yield comparable results over time.

If there is a 95% chance that personality tests will not help you predict the right recruits, your future leaders or your current staffing disconnects for where you are taking your business, what will?

Look for part two to this series here next week.

In the meantime, we’d love to hear from you on your successes and lessons learned in workforce assessments.

 

About the Author:

At the age of 9, Larry Cash’s life was almost destroyed by a test that concluded he was mentally challenged. In fact, Larry was dyslexic. A member of the Ontario Psychological Association and an International Affiliate of the American Psychological Association, he’s dedicated his life to understanding the intricacies of human behavior, working to develop training and testing that accurately looks at unique individuality and potential. Larry is the founder and developer of SuccessFinder, a talent assessment and career prediction platform that benchmarks behaviors from more than 40,000 highly successful professionals worldwide, across more than 500 roles.

Contact

Telephone Montreal : 514.687.2272​
Telephone Toronto : 416.590.9852​​
Toll Free : 844.932.3231

Find A Partner

We have a number of partners who can help you understand and implement SuccessFinder in your organization. Or, if you are looking for individual coaching, we have a network of certified practitioners we can put you in touch with. Just let us know the kind of need you have and your location and we’ll help.

Find Partner

Processing...
Thank you! Your subscription has been confirmed. You'll hear from us soon.
Subscribe to our blog
ErrorHere